People Savvy Blog

13 Things You Should Expect From Your Coach

by Nicola Payne

How to pick the right coach for you
This is 2nd in my Coaching Series where I try to demystify coaching and give you a sense of what it’s all about.  Today I want to share 13 things you should expect from your Coach. (It may just help you pick the right coach for you.)

~1~ Confidentiality – This is basics – but your coach should put you at absolute ease that everything you say to them remains 100% confidential. Any coach worth their salt will always hold this as a sacred rule and create a super safe space for you to say anything that you want or need to say.

~2~ Open to feedback - Everyone on this planet is different. Just think about that for a minute.    And so it follows that everyone’s needs are a tiny bit different.  Your coach may have a certain style - but they should flex it depending on what each of their clients need and your coach will probably sense when a change is needed.   That said, however talented they are, your coach will not always be a mind reader, so it is perfectly ok to tell them if you want something different e.g. a bit more challenge, some tough love or sometimes just to be there and listen and not coach at all.  They won’t be offended – they will be pleased you spoke up for what you want and need.

~3~ Tough love – A bit more on the topic of tough love. Us coaches love seeing growth and transformation in our clients.  And sometimes this requires that we tell the hard truth.  So your coach should have fierce courage to do this when required.  Remember they should always do this in service of you – to help you grow and develop.  Likewise, as mentioned above - if you want tough love – tell them up front.  It will make their job easier and they can always remind you of what you said you wanted when your nicey-nicey coach starts to sock it to you!

~4~ Comfortable with emotion – In my experience, lots of people start to apologise when tears flow or when anger rears it head. The words “I’m sorry” often come up.  There is no need to be sorry if you show deep emotion with your coach.  It is all good.  Your coach should have been trained to deal with this and will welcome emotion coming to the surface as it is often the start of a client getting to grips with what they really feel about a situation.  In addition, coaches are human too and have their own emotions.   Good coaches make sure they do their own work on themselves so they are able to be with whatever their client throws at them.

~5~ Thought provoking questions – Good questions should make you think deeply. Often they are really simple.  The best things usually are.  So ponder away.  If you find yourself answering questions on auto pilot and get a sense that the questions aren’t helping you do more than scratch the surface - tell your coach you need help to go deeper. They will probably know already, but just in case….

~6~ Challenge – A great coach will have a willingness to go deeper.  They will relish stretching you; getting down and dirty with your fears (in a good way) and pushing you out of your comfort zone so you achieve your potential. A challenge should scare you.  It should have give you the energy of “oooh – I couldn’t do that!!!”  And you always remain in control – you can say “yes”; “no” or suggest an alternative.

~7~ See who you are becoming – OK, I know this one sounds a bit fluffy but bear with me as it’s a biggie. People usually come to coaching to help them DO something e.g. get promoted, get a new job, improve relationships etc.   However as well as all of that, a great coach will help you transform deeply so that your mindset and whole way of being changes.  I like to think of it as becoming more of who you really are.  Without all the layers and years of conditioning about who you should be getting in your way.    Doing is only part of the battle – the real fun comes when you add in the being bit…..!

~8~ Hold you accountable. Most people can do with a serious injection of accountability to help them change whatever it is they want to change.  Resistance strikes when we least expecting it and it can be sooooo sneaky!   Your coach should be able to recognise when this is happening and work with you to get past it. Quite how you want them to do this is up to you.  Your coach isn’t your parent – they won’t tell you off if you don’t do what you said (although that can probably be arranged…..!!).  Your coach should however help you dig deep and figure out what’s getting in the way so you start to dissolve any resistance that’s holding you back.

~9~ Know when you may need more help than they are qualified to give.   Unless they have a dual career, your coach is unlikely to be a mental or physical health professional. So if they recognise or suspect you may have deep mental health issues; unresolved trauma or even physical symptoms that show up – they should talk to you about this.  They should encourage you to get any other professional help you may need.  Sometimes coaching can run parallel to this, sometimes coaching can come after.  Every situation is different and if a coach is in doubt, they should have a mentor or professional body to help guide them through.

~10~ Interesting tools and techniques – Coaching should be interesting, challenging and FUN! Yes – you should enjoy seeing your coach – and they should enjoy seeing you. If you are just doing the same old stuff or going through the motions – that can get boring and stop you growing and learning (which is the whole point of coaching after all!).   So if it aint interesting and at any point you aren’t feeling it – it is ok to walk away.  You can fire your coach and surprise surprise – they can fire you too!

~11~ Ability to raise your awareness – this sounds fundamental but is worth saying anyway. You should be learning from your coaching sessions. You should become more conscious of how you are being; where you get stuck; where you want to go.  You should be learning ways to do things differently, how to deal with resistance and to make change in your life.   You should become more resilient.  And you should be moving forwards towards your goals.  Your coach should be supporting you in all of this.  They may even include snippets of teaching, theory and recommend books and things that help you to learn.

~12~ Know when to speak and when to be silent. When a coach asks a really thought provoking question, you need some time to reflect on this. This can take – yes – TIME!  Most of us know how tempting it is to jump in and fill a silence and your coach should be experienced enough to know when you need clarification, help or when you just need space and time to reflect.  A minute can feel like an age but actually it’s not long at all.  So your coach should not be filling the silence or doing all the talking.  Silence can truly be golden.  It allows space for new stuff to come up in you.

~13~ Call you on your bullshit….I love this one. It’s great fun.   You know when you are bullshitting and your coach is likely to sense it too.  You are paying your hard earned money to your coach to help you make changes you want in your life.  So putting on a front, saying what you think you should in order to be a good client is not worth it.  A good coach will call you on this – they may do it gently or shock you with a full on challenge – remember it is all in service of you.

So that’s 13 and almost it for now – but just one final word.

And it’s a biggie.

This is a list of things you should expect from your coach, however to get this – YOU need to show up and do the work.  However great they are - miracles can’t happen without you.

Nicola x

>>> Piqued your interest?  Read my blog post on 11 things you need to know about working with a coach.

 

>>> If this has been helpful, you can get more inspiration and support on making changes in your life and career in Career Momentum, my online coaching and mentoring membership.

 

>>> And of course, if want to try out coaching with me, you can book a FREE intro session here.

Nicola is the Resident Coach at Hatmill, The Best Place to Work in the UK (2025), an ex-HR Director and the creator of Career Momentum: an online coaching and mentoring membership that gives you the space to think, the structure to act, and a coach in your corner when you need it most.

Head over to LinkedIn to connect with Nicola.

Join my email list

Inspiration to your inbox

I send a weekly (ish!) email sharing my take on those career moments in the corporate world
to give an injection of energy and insight when you need it most.

You can unsubscribe any time and I'll protect your details in accordance with my Privacy Policy.